Tuesday, April 29, 2014

Which Utopian Community Would You Choose By: Aaron Roberts

Which Utopian Community Would I Join? By Aaron Roberts

            If I had to choose a Utopian Community to join, it would probably be the Oneida community in New York.  John Humphrey Noyes started the Oneida community in 1948.   A big theme the Oneida community revolved around was pretty much sharing everything.  They practiced complex marriage, which was pretty much the men were married to the women and all the women were married to the men.  The Oneida community did not believe in monogamy, but sex was very important to them[1].  I think the idea of sharing is pretty cool, and I like sex so the Oneida community sounds pretty favorable over other ones like the shakers who were not allowed to have physical contact between sexes.  Having no physical contact between sexes sounds pretty shitty in fact, I wouldn’t wish that upon any heterosexual.  A draw back to being in the Oneida community for me would be the practice of coitus reservatus, which is that women were allowed to orgasm, but men could not orgasm.  They paired older women with young boys to teach them to control their orgasms.  I wouldn’t really want to suppress an orgasm, but suppressing an orgasm sounds much better then not having physical contact with the opposite sex.  Another custom of the Oneida community was stripiculture which was pretty much the board (comprised of 48 departments) selected who would reproduce with who, in order to breed certain traits.  The Oneida community did not last long however and had an array of issues including the deterioration of a main ideology they practiced, which was the complex marriage.  People would get jealous, and this formed monogamous marriages within the community, which ended up sending John Humphrey Noyes into exile[2].  Out of the other Utopian communities, the Oneida community sounded the most tolerable compared to how society is today, so that’s why I would pick that one to join out of the others communities.




[1] The Editors of Encyclopædia Britannica. "Oneida Community (utopian religious community)." Encyclopedia Britannica Online. http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/429132/Oneida-Community (accessed April 30, 2014).
[2] Moore, Crystal. “Utopian Communities in Victorian America” The History of Sexuality in America, Charlotte, NC, April 28, 2014.

No comments:

Post a Comment